Saturday, November 14, 2026

#57 - Marjorie Orbin *

Our first Vegas showgirl!

But would you believe Marjorie Orbin was also a stripper, a movie star (well, in a IMDb 3.5 stinker that her sugar daddy financed), and possibly in Motley Crue’s music video for “Girls, Girls, Girls”?

She may also have set a new record for most times married. Would you believe she tied the knot no less than 7 times by age 35? The 7th was Jay Orbin, a jewelry dealer, whom she met while stripping. 

And then, one day, Jay just disappeared. Marjorie said he was away on a business trip, but he seemed to have effectively vanished. Interestingly, though, he left his credit cards and checkbook at home, which Marjorie used to go on a spending spree.

Jay did, however, finally turn up. Unfortunately, it was as a torso in a plastic container found in the desert just a couple of miles from his home. Unfortunately for Marjorie, the container could be traced back to her, as well as a number of cleaning products. The couple’s garage had, in fact, been acid-washed and then treated with epoxy.

Why did she do it? Well, it seems Jay had uncovered an affair. And there was, of course, the money she would inherit.

At the trial, Marjorie would blame that boyfriend, claiming he threatened her and her son. A cellmate would also testify that Marjorie confessed to loathing Jay, as well as actually doing him in.  Though the trial would go on for 8 months, it took the jury only 7 hours to find her guilty, giving her life.



2004, Arizona




Saturday, November 7, 2026

#58 - Susan Grund *

Sue Ann Sanders was from the wrong side of the tracks in the rural Indiana town of Peru. James Grund, an attorney (and prosecutor) was from a prominent local family (with a father, grandfather, and uncle all serving as local judges). Somehow, they ended up together.

Susan (what she liked to call herself) was 1 of 7 children with an alcoholic, abusive father. She fled that scene by dropping out of high school at age 17, then moving to the big city of Kokomo. 

Before she was 24, Susan had been married 3 times, had 1 child, and was pregnant with another. She had a volatile temper, and had stabbed her 2nd husband in 2 different incidents. With her 3rd, she was convicted of battering his son from a previous marriage, leaving the boy bedridden with permanent brain damage. 

Though there doesn’t seem to have been any violence in her 4th marriage, the union was severely strained by Susan’s extravagant spending and her extensive sleeping around. Jimmy (what everyone called him) threatened divorce, and had actually gotten a lawyer and put his paperwork together for filing. 

And then he was shot. Susan claimed it was a botched burglary, but there was no evidence of forced entry, nothing was stolen, and the little disarray that was there looked staged. Further, Jimmy had been shot in the face seemingly while asleep.

Things, though, remained at a standstill. Susan, on the other hand, was very busy. First, she got started on claiming the quarter million in insurance money on Jimmy’s life. She also confided in her family that she had pulled the trigger, and that the gun was still in the house (inside a teddy bear, no less). Susan’s sister Darlene retrieved the bear, then she, Susan, and their mother put the gun in a pot then filled the pot with cement.

Darlene’s guilty conscience got the better of her, however, and after 2 months, she confessed. The gun was subsequently identified as belonging to Jimmy’s college-age son David. It had been reported stolen a month before the shooting, after Susan asked David, in passing, where he kept his firearms. The cops were then able to match the shell casing from the murder scene with a bullet that David had fired while taking target practice. 

None of this compared, though, with Susan’s explanation of it all at trial. She claimed that she and David were having an affair, that David wanted her all to himself, and that she concealed the gun to protect him. So, that impending divorce and the quarter million in insurance? That had nothing to do with it. Nothing whatsoever.

The jury wasn’t buying it, though, and gave Susan 60 years.



Indiana, 1992


Sunday, November 1, 2026

#59 - Jill Rockcastle *

If you’re going to do a murder-suicide and write a 10-page note confessing your guilt, it really does help to take all the pills. 

Bill Gistafik was a chiropractor turned bodybuilder and professional poker player (and known as “The Manipulator” for the latter). He and his surgically-enhanced wife, Jill Rockcastle. were addicted to the high life – coke, gambling, plastic surgery, a high-end Vegas condo (with the likes of Pamela Anderson and Leonardo DiCaprio as neighbors) …

They were also in debt, losing up to $70k a month. In addition, they were tax cheats and involved in scams. According to Jill, “We were living this fake life of millionaires. But we weren’t. We were going broke.” 

Bill also seem to be coming apart – addicted to pornography, abusing drugs, becoming violent with Rockcastle …  During a particularly viscous fight, she grabbed a knife and stabbed him 15 times. 

After an anonymous call to report the body, she fled to the California Coast, penned the suicide note, then took what she thought was an overdose. After 2 weeks in the ICU, she was ready for the trial. 

Despite pleading self-defense, she got 10 years to life. 


Nevada, 2016


Wednesday, October 28, 2026

#60 - Nancy Rish *

Ready for some big hair? Yup, this one comes from the 1980s alright. 

Danny Edwards and Nancy Rish lived in Bourbonnais, a town just south of Chicago. Danny, a small-time carpenter and former drug dealer, came up with a scheme to land them in some big-time money. 

In particular, he thought he’d kidnap a local swell, one Stephen Small. Small’s family-owned United Press International and was descended from a former Illinois governor. Small himself also owned a Frank Lloyd Wright house, in nearby Kankakee, which he was busy refurbishing

The first part of the scheme was actually pretty smart. Edwards called Small in the middle of the night pretending to be the local police and claiming that a break-in had just occurred at the house Small was remodeling. When Small showed up there alone in the dead of the night, he was pretty easy pickings. 

The second part of the scheme wasn’t so bad either – at least in theory. Edwards demanded $1M from Small’s wife, then placed Small in a 6x3 box underground. He provided him with water, food, even light. 

Unfortunately, he did not provide adequate ventilation. Instead of lasting the several days that Edwards had planned, Small asphyxiated within a couple of hours. 

The cops were able to trace Edwards’ calls from phone booths (remember those?) at several local gas stations. Witnesses at the stations remembered him and his very blonde girlfriend, as well as the details of their car.  

And that was what allowed the cops to show up at Danny and Nancy’s door and place them under arrest. Danny then very helpfully took them to the body.

At his trial, Danny would get the death penalty (though this would later be commuted to life). Rish made two claims at hers:

  • Ignorance – though she drove Edwards to and from the burial location, various phone booths, and stores where Edwards shopped for supplies
  • That Edwards had threatened to kill her son from another marriage if she didn’t go along with his plans

Yeah, they seem kinda conflicting to me too. Prosecutors also pointed to other inconsistencies Rish had made in her interviews with the cops.

Rish was eventually sentenced to life. Interestingly, she got out in 2022, the beneficiary of a new law that recognized the role that domestic violence can play in situations like hers (she was also a model prisoner). Rish was 60 when she tasted freedom once again (she was 26 at the time of the crime).



Illinois, 1987


Wednesday, October 21, 2026

#61 - Amy Bosley *

Sometimes, when you’re in a hole, the first thing you’ve gotta do is to just stop digging.

Bob and Amy Bosley owned a multimillion-dollar, roofing / chimney sweep business in northern Kentucky. The successful company afforded them all the trappings of a well-to-do lifestyle – sports cars, horses, a private plane, a 50-ft boat … Regular churchgoers, they also had 2 cute pre-teen children and seemed to have the perfect life.

Until, that is, their home was invaded and Bob was shot. Amy’s frantic 911 call claimed that the intruder was still in the house.

Police immediately, however, had their suspicions. First, it appeared that Bob had been shot 6 times while sleeping. His gun was also missing (it was later found in Amy’s purse), and 4 of the 6 shell casings were located in the washing machine. Also, the glass from the supposed break-in went in the wrong direction, and their kids reported hearing the glass break after the gunshots. Finally, though the house was ransacked, nothing of value was missing.

Coincidentally, Bob was due to meet with the IRS the next day. Unbeknownst to him, he owed $1.7M in unpaid taxes, something which Amy, as bookkeeper for the family business, had been hiding. Instead of admitting her error to her husband, and not wanting him to be surprised by the IRS, she panicked and decided to shoot him instead.

Amy negotiated a plea deal, and got 20 years. She was released in 2022. 



Kentucky, 2005


Wednesday, October 14, 2026

#62 - Linda Pedroza *

The brain’s frontal lobe regulates impulse control, social appropriateness, empathy, problem-solving, and decision-making. It’s not fully developed until the mid to late 20s. Which, of course, is why we get so many killers in their teens and early twenties. Killers like 17-year-old Linda Pedroza.

Linda and her mom, Isabel, just didn’t get along. Linda, a high-school dropout, sounds like quite a handful. Isabel objected in particular, though, to the man she was dating, 23-year-old ex-con Antoine Wright.

After a fight about the relationship, Isabel – at least according to Linda – stormed out of the house, telling Linda that she was going to Texas to see a relative. After 3 days with no word from her, or Texas, Linda reported Isabel as missing. 

A couple of weeks later, a surveyor discovered a decomposed body in some remote pine scrub. Wrapped around the neck was an electrical cord, which made the cops immediately suspect foul play. 

There was no identification on the body, though the deceased was wearing some very unique jewelry. Combing through missing person reports, the police thought Isabel might be a possible match. They took the jewelry to where Isabel worked, and a coworker was able to identify it as hers.

After a media blitz, a friend of Linda’s came forward saying that Isabel’s car was at the airport. This made some sense, given Isabel’s plans. The friend, though, also claimed that he had driven the car there, with the couple giving him a ride back. At the time, this witness had known nothing of Isabel’s disappearance.

With a search warrant in hand, the cops searched the house where Isabel and Linda (and now Antoine) lived. They didn’t find anything, except for a rather suspicious lamp that was missing its cord. 

After several interrogations, Linda finally cracked. Needless to say, she blamed everything on Antoine.   

According to Linda, Antoine first hit Isabel on the head with a frying pan. He then strangled her with an electrical cord, though Linda also admitted that she had helped. Not knowing what to do with the body, they first tried dissolving it with muriatic acid. When that didn’t work, they wrapped it up in a tarp, then dumped it in the woods. 

Using some money that Isabel had hidden, the couple celebrated with a dinner at Denny’s, then tattoos of each other’s names. They also bought a camera, which they used to take shots of them shopping, partying, and generally having a grand time.

Oddly, Linda would not cop a deal by testifying against Antoine. He, however, had no problem testifying against her, getting a 20-year sentence for 2nd degree murder. To avoid the chair, Linda pled guilty, getting a 40-year sentence. 


2000, Florida


Wednesday, October 7, 2026

#63 - Ezra McCandless *

Manic pixie dream girl alert! Manic pixie dream girl alert!

The glasses! The hair! The lipstick! The nose ring! The weird name! The stabbing your ex-boyfriend 16 times.

Ezra McCandless was a 20-year-old college dropout who fashioned herself something of an artist. She liked to adorn her older car with “art,” then drive it around her adopted town of Eau Claire, WI (the “indie capital of the midwest”).

Ezra had some gender issues, and liked to call herself “they.” She had also legally changed her name from Monica Kay.

Ezra was also trying to juggle no less than 3 boyfriends. The one she was closest with, Jason Mengal, had 14 years on her. In classic manic-pixie-dream-girl form, that simply “made him more spontaneous.”

The second was Alex Woodworth, their barista and something of a mutual friend. Jason had actually made an effort to put the two together, thinking they had some shared interests and that Alex could her help work out some issues. The third was John Hansen, who Jason also asked to look after Ezra (when he did his 2-week duty in the Guard). Somehow or other, she ended up in bed with both. 

Invariably, Jason found out. Having been juggling 3 boyfriends, Ezra now found herself without any. With her tail between her legs, she slunk back to her little hometown of Stanley.

A year and a half later, though, she returned to Eau Claire, with some sort of confrontation taking place between herself and Alex. The police were called, but then everything seemed to blow over. 

The next thing we know Ezra shows up at some farm in the middle of nowhere, covered in mud, blood, and bruises, claiming she was the victim of an assault. She also claimed that she had no idea how she had gotten there, or even who she was. The only clue was the word “boy” carved on her arm.

The next day, her car was found near the farm, stuck in the mud, and with Alex’s body hanging out of the back seat. All of a sudden, Ezra’s memory started to come back to her. She claimed that Alex had assaulted her, carved “boy” into her arm, and attacked her with a knife. She then grabbed it from him and stabbed him to death in self-defense.

There were, however, some issues with her story. First, the medical staff believed that her wounds had been self-inflicted. Ezra, in turn, admitted that she had carved the “boy” herself. The knife was also traced back to her. There were other holes in her story as well.

During the subsequent trial, Ezra played the manic pixie dream girl to full tilt – smiling, laughing, making jokes … The jury took 3 hours to convict. Despite a tearful (though of questionable sincerity) apology, Ezra was sentenced to life with a possibility of parole after a mere 50 years.

She’s trying to fund her appeals by selling her artwork. You can find her on Facebook!



2018, Wisconsin