Ready for some big hair? Yup, this one comes from the 1980s alright.
Danny Edwards and Nancy Rish lived in Bourbonnais, a town just south of Chicago. Danny, a small-time carpenter and former drug dealer, came up with a scheme to land them in some big-time money.
In particular, he thought he’d kidnap a local swell, one Stephen Small. Small’s family-owned United Press International and was descended from a former Illinois governor. Small himself also owned a Frank Lloyd Wright house, in nearby Kankakee, which he was busy refurbishing
The first part of the scheme was actually pretty smart. Edwards called Small in the middle of the night pretending to be the local police and claiming that a break-in had just occurred at the house Small was remodeling. When Small showed up there alone in the dead of the night, he was pretty easy pickings.
The second part of the scheme wasn’t so bad either – at least in theory. Edwards demanded $1M from Small’s wife, then placed Small in a 6x3 box underground. He provided him with water, food, even light.
Unfortunately, he did not provide adequate ventilation. Instead of lasting the several days that Edwards had planned, Small asphyxiated within a couple of hours.
The cops were able to trace Edwards’ calls from phone booths (remember those?) at several local gas stations. Witnesses at the stations remembered him and his very blonde girlfriend, as well as the details of their car.
And that was what allowed the cops to show up at Danny and Nancy’s door and place them under arrest. Danny then very helpfully took them to the body.
At his trial, Danny would get the death penalty (though this would later be commuted to life). Rish made two claims at hers:
- Ignorance – though she drove Edwards to and from the burial location, various phone booths, and stores where Edwards shopped for supplies
- That Edwards had threatened to kill her son from another marriage if she didn’t go along with his plans
Yeah, they seem kinda conflicting to me too. Prosecutors also pointed to other inconsistencies Rish had made in her interviews with the cops.
Rish was eventually sentenced to life. Interestingly, she got out in 2022, the beneficiary of a new law that recognized the role that domestic violence can play in situations like hers (she was also a model prisoner). Rish was 60 when she tasted freedom once again (she was 26 at the time of the crime).
Illinois, 1987





















