Saturday, November 7, 2026

#58 - Susan Grund *

Sue Ann Sanders was from the wrong side of the tracks in the rural Indiana town of Peru. James Grund, an attorney (and prosecutor) was from a prominent local family (with a father, grandfather, and uncle all serving as local judges). Somehow, they ended up together.

Susan (what she liked to call herself) was 1 of 7 children with an alcoholic, abusive father. She fled that scene by dropping out of high school at age 17, then moving to the big city of Kokomo. 

Before she was 24, Susan had been married 3 times, had 1 child, and was pregnant with another. She had a volatile temper, and had stabbed her 2nd husband in 2 different incidents. With her 3rd, she was convicted of battering his son from a previous marriage, leaving the boy bedridden with permanent brain damage. 

Though there doesn’t seem to have been any violence in her 4th marriage, the union was severely strained by Susan’s extravagant spending and her extensive sleeping around. Jimmy (what everyone called him) threatened divorce, and had actually gotten a lawyer and put his paperwork together for filing. 

And then he was shot. Susan claimed it was a botched burglary, but there was no evidence of forced entry, nothing was stolen, and the little disarray that was there looked staged. Further, Jimmy had been shot in the face seemingly while asleep.

Things, though, remained at a standstill. Susan, on the other hand, was very busy. First, she got started on claiming the quarter million in insurance money on Jimmy’s life. She also confided in her family that she had pulled the trigger, and that the gun was still in the house (inside a teddy bear, no less). Susan’s sister Darlene retrieved the bear, then she, Susan, and their mother put the gun in a pot then filled the pot with cement.

Darlene’s guilty conscience got the better of her, however, and after 2 months, she confessed. The gun was subsequently identified as belonging to Jimmy’s college-age son David. It had been reported stolen a month before the shooting, after Susan asked David, in passing, where he kept his firearms. The cops were then able to match the shell casing from the murder scene with a bullet that David had fired while taking target practice. 

None of this compared, though, with Susan’s explanation of it all at trial. She claimed that she and David were having an affair, that David wanted her all to himself, and that she concealed the gun to protect him. So, that impending divorce and the quarter million in insurance? That had nothing to do with it. Nothing whatsoever.

The jury wasn’t buying it, though, and gave Susan 60 years.



Indiana, 1992


No comments:

Post a Comment